IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF HAWAII
August 23, 2012
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
KOLAIAH JARDINE, DEFENDANT.
The opinion of the court was delivered by: Susan Oki Mollway Chief United States District Judge
ORDER DENYING DEFENDANT
KOLAIAH JARDINE'S MOTION FOR
PERMISSION TO TRAVEL
ORDER DENYING DEFENDANT KOLAIAH JARDINE'S MOTION FOR PERMISSION TO TRAVEL
Defendant KOLAIAH Jardine seeks permission to travel to the Big Island for a week to visit his ailing grandmother. The court is sympathetic, and travel for that very purpose has indeed been approved multiple times over the past years. The present request, however, is denied for several reasons.
First, it is unclear what the status of Jardine's grandmother's health is at present, and a doctor's note in that regard would be helpful, as noted in the Government's opposition.
Second, it is unclear why a weeklong visit is requested, as opposed to only a weekend. When the court imposed the revocation sentence, Jardine said he would use accrued vacation time to cover his incarceration period, so that he could return to his job when released. If he then began his new supervision period with no remaining accrued vacation time, and if any travel would involve unpaid leave, the court is concerned that Jardine may not be evaluating his financial situation realistically. Moreover, it may not be the wisest decision to take unpaid leave given the relatively short time he has spent back on the job post-incarceration.
Third, Jardine is only a few months into his new supervision term, and travel this early in a supervision term is rarely permitted. Of course, the court is willing to make appropriate exceptions, and the court does want to encourage Jardine to maintain his positive family contacts. Concern over an ailing relative is commendable. However, Jardine has not provided sufficient information to establish that an exception is appropriate at this time.
Fourth, Jardine's travel risks interrupting his substance abuse treatment. While he suggests that he be drug-tested on the Big Island, he makes no suggestion with respect to possible disruption of the counseling schedule.
The court encourages Jardine to renew his motion after providing further information to Probation and after carefully considering his employment, financial, and treatment situations and possibly modifying his request accordingly. Jardine no doubt recalls that the court went to considerable lengths to accommodate his circumstances, particularly his paddleboarding competitions, in fashioning his revocation sentence. Jardine must now take responsibility for establishing the appropriateness of further accommodation. He has not done that on the present motion.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Susan Oki Mollway
© 1992-2012 VersusLaw Inc.